renal

AKI vs CKD

When the kidneys fail fast vs when they fail slow — and why boards makes you tell the difference

Before you scroll...

A 58-year-old man with diabetes presents with Cr 4.2 mg/dL (baseline unknown). Ultrasound shows bilateral small kidneys (8 cm). Which finding most suggests this is chronic rather than acute?

Good instinct. Small kidneys = chronic scarring = CKD. AKI kidneys are normal or large (swollen from acute insult). This is the single fastest way boards distinguishes the two. Elevated BUN:Cr and hyperkalemia happen in both. Oliguria happens in both. But small kidneys can't happen overnight — that takes months to years of damage.
The Core Split

AKI — Acute Kidney Injury

  • Hours to days
  • Cr rises ≥0.3 mg/dL in 48h or ≥1.5x baseline in 7 days
  • Often reversible
  • Kidneys: normal or large on US
  • No anemia (usually)
  • No bone disease
  • Can progress to CKD if severe/prolonged

CKD — Chronic Kidney Disease

  • Months to years
  • GFR <60 mL/min for ≥3 months
  • Usually irreversible
  • Kidneys: small and scarred on US
  • Anemia (low EPO)
  • Renal osteodystrophy (low vitamin D, high PTH)
  • Can have AKI on top of CKD ("acute on chronic")
Board Trap: "Acute on chronic" is real and common. A CKD patient who gets dehydrated or takes NSAIDs gets an AKI superimposed on their CKD. Cr jumps above their usual elevated baseline. Boards tests whether you recognize both components.
🔍 AKI Classification — Where's the Problem?

The three types of AKI map to where the blood flow is blocked or damaged:

Problem: Not enough blood getting TO the kidney. The kidney itself is fine.

  • Causes: Dehydration, hemorrhage, heart failure, sepsis, NSAIDsNSAIDs constrict the afferent arteriole, reducing renal blood flow. This is prerenal injury because the kidney parenchyma is undamaged — it's just not getting enough flow., ACE inhibitorsACEi/ARBs dilate the efferent arteriole, dropping filtration pressure. Again, the kidney itself is fine — it's the hemodynamics that change.
  • Labs: BUN:Cr >20:1, FENa <1%, concentrated urine (high specific gravity), bland sediment
  • Key insight: The kidney is trying to hold on to everything because it thinks the body is dry. So sodium is low in urine (FENa <1%), urine is concentrated, BUN is reabsorbed disproportionately.
💡 Prerenal = the kidney is a good employee dealing with a bad situation. It's working perfectly — just not getting enough to work with.
🔑 Memory hook (tap to reveal)
PRErenal = PREtend the kidney is fine. Because it IS fine. It's just thirsty. Give it fluids and it recovers.

Problem: The kidney itself is damaged. Tubules, glomeruli, or interstitium.

  • ATN (Acute Tubular Necrosis): Most common intrinsic AKI. Ischemic (from prolonged prerenal) or nephrotoxic (aminoglycosidesGentamicin, tobramycin — accumulate in proximal tubular cells and cause direct toxicity. Classic board answer for drug-induced ATN., contrast dye, myoglobin)
  • AIN (Acute Interstitial Nephritis): Drug hypersensitivity reaction. Triad: fever, rash, eosinophilia. Think penicillins, sulfonamides, NSAIDs, PPIs
  • Glomerulonephritis: RPGN, lupus nephritis, anti-GBM — see nephrotic vs nephritic page

Labs: BUN:Cr <20:1, FENa >2% (in ATN), muddy brown casts (ATN), WBC casts + eosinophils (AIN), RBC casts (GN)

💡 Intrinsic = the kidney itself is broken. It can't concentrate urine or reabsorb sodium properly anymore. That's why FENa is >2% — sodium is leaking out.
🔑 Memory hook (tap to reveal)
Muddy brown casts = ATN. Think of the tubular cells sloughing off like mud sliding down a pipe. Nothing else gives you muddy brown casts. If you see them, it's ATN. Done.

Problem: Urine can't get OUT. Obstruction downstream of the kidney.

  • Causes: BPH (most common in older men), kidney stones (bilateral or solitary kidney), cancer (cervical, bladder, prostate), neurogenic bladder
  • Diagnosis: Ultrasound shows hydronephrosis (dilated collecting system)
  • Treatment: Relieve the obstruction. Foley catheter for BPH, stent or nephrostomy for stones/cancer
💡 Postrenal is the easiest to diagnose (US shows hydro) and the most important to rule out first because it's immediately fixable.
Board Trap: A single ureteral stone does NOT cause AKI if the other kidney is normal. You need BILATERAL obstruction or obstruction of a solitary functioning kidney.
📊 The Board Table — AKI vs CKD at a Glance
Feature AKI CKD
Timeline Hours to days Months to years
Kidney size (US) Normal or large Small (<9 cm bilateral)
Anemia Usually absent Present (low EPO)
Bone disease Absent Renal osteodystrophy
Broad waxy casts No Yes
Reversibility Often reversible Usually irreversible
Hyperkalemia Yes Yes (late stage)
Metabolic acidosis Yes Yes
Edema/fluid overload Yes Yes
PTH Normal Elevated (secondary hyperPTH)
Phosphate Can be elevated Chronically elevated
Calcium Variable Low (can't activate vitamin D)
Board Trap: The CKD bone disease chain: low GFR → can't excrete phosphate → high PO4 binds calcium → low Ca → PTH rises to compensate → bones get chewed up (osteitis fibrosa cystica). This is secondary hyperparathyroidism.
🧬 The Board-Favorite Lab Battle: Prerenal vs ATN

This comparison shows up on almost every exam. The kidney's response tells you if the tubules still work.

Lab Prerenal ATN (Intrinsic)
BUN:Cr >20:1 <20:1
FENa <1% >2%
Urine Na <20 mEq/L >40 mEq/L
Urine osmolality >500 mOsm/kg <350 mOsm/kg
Specific gravity >1.020 <1.010
Urine sediment Bland / hyaline casts Muddy brown granular casts
Response to fluids Cr improves Cr does NOT improve
💡 The logic: In prerenal, the kidney works hard to save sodium and concentrate urine because it senses low perfusion. In ATN, the tubules are dead — they can't reabsorb sodium or concentrate anything. FENa is the single best discriminator.
🔑 Memory hook (tap to reveal)
FENa <1% = kidney is trying (it's holding onto sodium for dear life). FENa >2% = kidney gave up (tubules are broken, sodium falls right through). Think of it as: low FENa = low failure. High FENa = high failure.
Board Trap: FENa is unreliable in patients on diuretics (falsely elevated). Use FEUrea <35% instead — urea handling is independent of diuretics. Boards loves this exception.
🛠 AKI Workup Algorithm

Step through this when you see rising creatinine on boards:

Step 1: Is there obstruction?

Get a renal ultrasound. Look for hydronephrosis.

US shows bilateral hydronephrosis. What type of AKI?

Step 2: Check volume status

Dry mucous membranes? Tachycardia? Orthostatic hypotension? Give a fluid challenge.

Cr improves with IV fluids. What type?

Step 3: Check FENa and sediment

FENa <1% with bland sediment = prerenal (still not responding to fluids? Check cardiac output). FENa >2% = intrinsic. Look at casts.

Muddy brown casts + FENa 4%. Diagnosis?

Step 4: Identify the intrinsic cause

Sediment tells you everything:

  • Muddy brown casts = ATN
  • WBC casts + eosinophils = AIN (drug reaction)
  • RBC casts = Glomerulonephritis
  • Bland sediment with intrinsic labs = consider vascular (TTP, HUS, renal vein thrombosis)

Patient started amoxicillin 2 weeks ago. Now has fever, rash, eosinophilia, and WBC casts. Diagnosis?

📈 CKD Staging — Know the GFR Cutoffs

Boards expects you to know what happens at each stage:

StageGFR (mL/min)What's HappeningAction
1≥90Kidney damage, normal GFRManage risk factors, ACEi/ARB if proteinuria
260-89Mild decreaseEstimate progression rate
3a45-59Mild-moderateMonitor complications, adjust drug doses
3b30-44Moderate-severeRefer to nephrology
415-29Severe. Bone disease, anemia, acidosisPrepare for RRT, AV fistula
5<15Kidney failureDialysis or transplant
💡 Stage 4 is when you start planning the fistula. Takes 3-6 months to mature. If you wait until stage 5, patient gets a temporary catheter instead (higher infection risk). Boards loves: "When do you place the AV fistula?" Answer: GFR <30.
Board Trap: CKD Stage 1-2 requires evidence of kidney damage (proteinuria, abnormal imaging, abnormal biopsy) even though GFR is preserved. GFR alone isn't enough for Stage 1-2 diagnosis.
CKD Complications — The Cascade

Everything connects. Low GFR starts a chain reaction:

🔑 Memory hook (tap to reveal)
Indications for emergent dialysis: AEIOU
A = Acidosis (refractory)
E = Electrolytes (hyperK refractory to medical treatment)
I = Ingestion (toxic alcohols, lithium, salicylates)
O = Overload (fluid, refractory to diuretics)
U = Uremia (pericarditis, encephalopathy, bleeding)
🔀 Sort It — AKI vs CKD vs Both

Drag each feature to the correct category:

Muddy brown casts
Small kidneys on US
Hyperkalemia
Anemia from low EPO
FENa <1% (prerenal)
Secondary hyperPTH
Elevated creatinine
Responds to IV fluids
Broad waxy casts
Hydronephrosis (postrenal)
Low vitamin D
Metabolic acidosis
WBC casts + eosinophils
Needs AV fistula at GFR <30
AKI
CKD
Both
🛠 Clinical Decision Tree: Rising Creatinine

Work through a patient with new Cr elevation:

Patient presents with Cr 3.8 (was 1.0 last month). What's your FIRST step?

Good. US shows NO hydronephrosis, normal-sized kidneys. Now what?

You've ruled out postrenal obstruction and the kidneys aren't small (not chronic). This is AKI.

Not quite.

Always rule out obstruction first with ultrasound. Postrenal AKI is the easiest to fix and the most dangerous to miss. FENa comes AFTER you rule out obstruction.

Way too aggressive.

Biopsy is reserved for when non-invasive workup doesn't give you the answer. Start with ultrasound to rule out obstruction.

Patient is tachycardic, dry mucous membranes. You give 2L NS. Cr drops to 2.1 in 24h.

Cr is responding to fluids. What's your diagnosis?

Not quite.

ATN does NOT respond to fluids — the tubules are dead. If Cr improves with IV fluids, the kidney was underperfused but structurally intact. That's prerenal.

No. Way too early.

Dialysis is for refractory hyperK, acidosis, fluid overload, or uremic symptoms (AEIOU). You haven't even figured out what's causing the AKI yet. Assess volume status first — most AKI is prerenal and fixes with fluids.

Correct. Prerenal AKI from dehydration.

Key takeaways:

1. Always US first to rule out obstruction
2. Fluid challenge before labs — if it responds, you have your answer
3. FENa <1% confirms prerenal, but clinical response to fluids is the real test
4. If fluids DON'T work → check FENa and sediment → intrinsic AKI workup

🎯 Elimination Game — 6 Scenarios

Boards gives you a vignette. You tell them what's happening:

Scenario 1 of 6

72M with BPH presents with Cr 5.1 (baseline 0.9). US shows bilateral hydronephrosis. No prior renal disease.

Bilateral hydronephrosis + BPH = classic postrenal obstruction. Foley catheter first, then urology consult. Cr was normal at baseline so this is acute, not chronic.

Scenario 2 of 6

45F with SLE presents with Cr 2.8, bilateral small kidneys (8.5 cm), Hgb 9.2, PTH 180 (elevated). No recent medication changes.

Three classic CKD markers: small kidneys, anemia, and elevated PTH. These take months to years to develop. This is chronic damage from lupus nephritis, not an acute flare.

Scenario 3 of 6

68M with CHF (EF 20%) presents with Cr 3.2 (baseline 1.1). BUN:Cr 28:1. FENa 0.4%. Urine concentrated. Bland sediment.

BUN:Cr >20:1, FENa <1%, concentrated urine, bland sediment = textbook prerenal. The low EF means the heart isn't pumping enough blood to the kidneys. Treat the heart failure, not the kidneys.

Scenario 4 of 6

55M post-cardiac surgery. Cr was 1.0 pre-op, now 4.5 on day 3. FENa 3.8%. Urine sediment shows muddy brown granular casts.

Post-surgical setting + FENa >2% + muddy brown casts = ischemic ATN. During surgery, the kidneys got inadequate blood flow long enough to kill the tubular cells. Supportive care — tubules regenerate in 1-3 weeks if the patient survives.

Scenario 5 of 6

30F started TMP-SMX 10 days ago for UTI. Now has fever, maculopapular rash, Cr 2.4 (baseline 0.8). CBC shows eosinophilia. Urine: WBC casts, eosinophiluria.

Classic AIN triad: fever, rash, eosinophilia after starting a new drug. WBC casts and eosinophiluria confirm interstitial inflammation. Treatment: stop the drug, consider steroids. This is a hypersensitivity reaction, NOT dose-dependent toxicity.

Scenario 6 of 6

62M marathon runner found unconscious. Cr 6.8. CPK 45,000. Urine is dark brown. Urine dipstick: positive for blood. Microscopy: NO RBCs.

Dipstick positive for "blood" but NO RBCs on microscopy = myoglobinuria. The dipstick can't tell myoglobin from hemoglobin. CPK 45,000 confirms rhabdomyolysis — muscle breakdown releases myoglobin that's toxic to tubules. Treat with aggressive IV fluids to flush the myoglobin out.
🎓 Quiz — Board-Style Questions